Video: Threat Briefing | Holiday Fraud Trends and Tactics | Duration: 3476s | Summary: Threat Briefing | Holiday Fraud Trends and Tactics | Chapters: Welcome to Webinar (3.44s), Carding: Fraud's Origin (68.08s), E-Skimmer Fraud Evolution (239.14s), Dark Web Trends (478.45s), Card Data Exploitation (772.375s), Fraud Ecosystem Explained (958.91s), Advanced Phishing Techniques (1161.75s), Scam Sites Unveiled (1296.99s), Scam Merchant Monitoring (1474.03s), Holiday Scam Tactics (1530.38s), Evolving Scam Tactics (1594.805s), Holiday Scam Tactics (1758.94s), Redirect Scam Techniques (1945.795s), Advanced Scam Techniques (2089.07s), Job Fraud Schemes (2210.31s), Crypto Recruitment Scams (2380.075s), Pig Butchering Scams (2566.66s), Tax Refund Fraud (2698.92s), New Account Fraud (2860.855s), Conclusion and Q&A (3118.14s), Concluding Scam Prevention (3317.11s)
Transcript for "Threat Briefing | Holiday Fraud Trends and Tactics":
Hello, and welcome to our, webinar, where we will try to secure our world with intelligence, and we will try and secure the digital economy. In today's presentation, we are gonna be talking about holiday fraud trends and tactics. Now the topic is broad, so bear with us, as we are trying to sort of navigate this complex topic. We will be talking about fraud more generally. We'll be talking about scams and scam sites, and we'll be talking about the wide range of things that are happening in the world of fraud. There's many different terminologies, that we're gonna be using. We'll be going on a surface level, and we'll be diving a little bit now and then, and then we'll be coming up on a surface level. What that means for you is that if you are highly specialized and you want some interesting details, you will have that. If you're not highly specialized, there will still be a lot of interesting things for you to learn. We're not gonna be super technical here, but we'll happily answer any technical questions. So, your presenters are myself. I'm Ilya Bolovic. I'm director of payment fraud intelligence team here at Recorded Future. And, partnering with me will be Karina Borzenkova. So she's the senior payment fraud intelligence analyst who works on my team. So she, was gracious enough to help me put together this presentation. So she we will be co presenting, at various stages. So let's start here. Again, the term fraud is very broad, and I wanna sort of build out the foundation for everybody so people understand kind of where we're coming from. One of the oldest types of fraud is carding. Carding, believe it or not, what we believe is the godfather of fraud. This is where you steal payment cards and then you do crime. This goes back way back to the nineties when, there was a country called Soviet Union. That country fell apart in '91. And then there were a lot of programmers that were left jobless. They didn't have jobs. They didn't have money. And, you know, they got together and they're like, hey. We can actually steal some credit cards from America, you know, the bad West. So they came out with ways how they can steal cards. And then they said, well, we have to have a way how we can communicate in secret. So, there was this tour network that was available, and they decided to create forums where they can communicate with each other. Thus came the dark web forums. This was kinda gave birth to that. They kinda the way we know the dark web and dark web forums, if you're familiar with it now, that's what was the start of it. So carding and payment card fraud is, in many ways, really the godfather of fraud. So when we talk about how they stole the cards way back when, one of the ways was physical skimmers. You can see on the screen here, this is an older device. Well, not older device. This is a newer device, but it it it goes back many many years, decades, I should say. And this is essentially when, you know, you you have an overlay device, a physical overlay over a physical, payment machine. Right? This could be a gas station where you're sliding in your car. This could be on ATM, or it can be your seven eleven or what have you. It's an overlay device. You swipe your card, and on the back of your card, you have a magnetic stripe. That magnetic stripe is read by that overlay device. Then you put in a pin. Well, you have a little pin tab there that will copy that pin, and now you have what's called track two data. So that's the original physical skimmer. And again, back in the day, this is how most of this carding was happening. As we evolve as society and as things globally are changing, the way we steal data is changing. The way we do shopping is changing. You probably are getting ready for this holiday season. Back in the day, you would go to the mall and stand in long lines and try and pick and choose things and, you know, it's a difficult time. Nowadays, what do you do? You go online. Right? And you're like, hey, I'm gonna do some online shopping here. Well, alright. That's one thing. And then the second thing, you know, as an industry, we also looked at, like, look, we have these physical skimmers. They steal cards. That's not safe. Let's come up with some ways to, you know, stop that kind of crime. You know, let's maybe make some chips. Right? So now we have most cards have chips. Right? And that kinda sort of, you know, what's fighting that physical skimmer crime. Well, again, the move to the online, the physical sort of, implementation that we made in this industry on on on physical cards kinda driven criminals into other directions. And now we have what's called an e skimmer. So, just like an overlay device you have on a physical device, we slide the card and they steal data. Now we have something called mage card. Mage card is essentially when you have an ecommerce site, a website, you know, you go shopping on. You take things, you put them in the cart, and then you go to a checkout page. There will be an overlay. Only this time, it's not a physical one, it's a digital one. And as you're putting in your credit card number, your address, your email, your phone number, and whatever other data you put on there, that digital e skimmer, that overlay will steal all that data. So that's the modern way that criminals are doing it. And, so this is sort of the backbone of the fraud as we know it, as we see it. And then there's another new element that came into play, and this new element is scam sites. Now phishing has been around and scams is kinda part of this global phishing things and or phishing is part of scams, however you wanna define it. But, purchase scams have become a player in this play field. They are stealing card data. So then you ask, well, what happens to that card data once they stolen it? Right? Well, how many cards are they actually stealing? We'll get to that in the next slides. But here on my slide, you can see a couple of examples of what we call carding shops. These are specialized dark web stores where criminals that steal those cards, whether they're physical skimmers or the e skimmers, they then try and sell them. They're not gonna try and sell them themselves. It's kinda like, you know, with jewelry. You know, you have a little ring. You're not trying to sell you sell it to somebody that sells jewelry. Right? Similarly, criminals that are stealing cards, a lot of times, they're gonna go to a store that sells cards. So these are specialized stores. As you can tell, they look very fairly advanced. There's a lot of cool options. Kinda like almost eBay or Amazon, if you will. You have an option. You can select, hey. I want these bins, or I want, credit cards from this ZIP code, or I want, credit cards with this last name, or whatever your desire is. You have the different filter options. You can pick and choose what kind of credit cards you wanna buy. Credit cards are not expensive. They're about $15. Buy that, and then you go shopping. So, you know, the that that whole criminal infrastructure is fairly interesting. And again, it is fairly resilient. We have a lot of different events that are sort of influencing this, and we'll talk about that on the next slides. But I want you to keep in mind that this is sort of, one of the areas that that is still kind of playing a huge role in this sort of dark web and, cybercrime infrastructure. Down on the bottom, you're gonna see a chart. And remember how I talked about physical skimmers? And some of you probably, you know, are in the industry and you remember those physical skimmers. That has been dying. That is a very small percentage of this whole economy or dark web economy. That chart on the bottom can actually show you that these e skimmers are really getting a rise and card not present, which is, you know, physical skimmers card present. That's presently the card you stole, and card not present is card you use online with the card number. That has started to rise. And there was, an event in, you know, in 2020 that kinda gave this whole thing a push, maybe 2021, where, you know, maybe people couldn't go out as much, start to use online a little bit more. Let's get to the next slide, talk about the trends. And this is a little bit of a product placement. You probably know that, you know, we we we are Telstra's company and and my department specifically, we focus on carding. We focus on the the collection monitoring of the dark web for these cars being out there. So we have a pretty good sense of what is happening in this market. We've been at it for many years now. So let's look at this graph. So if we look at 2021, there were about 90,000,000 cards for sale on the dark web. And if you look at 2020, probably a little bit less. But in 2021, if we go back about five year four or five years, we see that it was about 90, million. The dark blue is actually your card not present stuff. This is the online shopping. This is your card number, CVV address. And the the light blue is card present. This is from your regular skimmers. And as I can see over the years, that card present is really going down, especially 2021, 2022. What happened in 2020 starting 2020 and spreading into 2122? That's right. COVID nineteen. This was a big large event that was happening. People were getting locked in in their homes. They couldn't go out shopping anymore. The whole economy sort of shifted into this ecommerce. It was shifting before. Right? We were getting more accustomed to Amazon and online shopping, But COVID nineteen really kinda gave this big push towards that. And again, criminals are like, okay. Well, look, we you know, it's harder to steal now the cards that are physically there, and it's harder for us to do cash outs with those cards because, you know, what? Once they steal a card, they need to put it on another card and then they go physically shop, but everything is locked down. So it's a lot easier to do shopping online. Another interesting event was happening in 2022 that really had an interesting sort of, input or or or, sort of shade on this market. And this is the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Before Russia invaded Ukraine, Russia did an and this is what influenced this sort of market and and, like, the supply of cards. Russia started arresting hackers. This is sort of signaling to the West. Look, you guys don't look what we're doing. This is our theory. This is not maybe a 100% true, but this is out there. Russia was signaling to the West. Look. You guys close your eyes on what we're doing with Ukraine, and we're gonna curve this hacker problem. If you're in an industry, you know that, you know, hackers sort of feel safe in Russia, if you will. And they felt safe doing whatever they were doing. But at this time, Russia was like, hey. Look. We know who the hackers are. We're gonna arrest them as long as you guys don't meddle with our business here in Ukraine. And that's what they did. So in the 2021, 2022, they started shutting down carding shops, these dark web marketplaces, you know, the the Russian KGB or FSB, however you wanna call them, would come in there and arrest the hackers. So that really scared a lot of hackers, and they were like, oh my god. What do we do now? So we see that in the marketplace. We see that, in in the supply. And then again, the West didn't really care. We still kinda impose sanctions on Russia, and we started this sort of cold war. Number two, so the market resurged, and the market resurged with the vengeance. The other reason market resurged with the vengeance is that we started to get other players on the market. Remember how we outsource a lot of things to different countries? Well, as we outsource things, we obviously train people in how to do things, how we operate, what how our systems operate, how to do customer care, how to do all these different things. And we became a very globalized society. We became very accustomed to, you know, that globalized society. So we saw an influx of other players, not just the Russian speaker. I don't wanna say it's all Russian. It's Russian speakers called Soyen. Right? We saw other players enter the market, and these players were from Asia. This is the Asian countries in in that, the Far East Asia, if you wanna call it. We saw a lot of players get into this sort of fraud scam and and carding and everything else. So that gave a boost to this economy, the dark web economy, if you will, and the carding economy. So in 2024, we saw enormous amount of cards being posted for sale. 180,000,000 in 2024 cards posted for sale on the dark web marketplaces. That's insane. That's double what was posted in 2023. And again, look at that dark blue. That's card not present. These are the cards they are getting from ecommerce sites. They're stealing that, right, with these match card stealers. In 2025, we are kinda on track. We are sort of on track. We are very close to the same numbers. But interestingly, what we noticed is certain trends. So if we look at the numbers for 2024, we noticed that 73% of those cards that were for sale actually had cardholder email address and phone numbers. However, in 2025, that percentage risen to 80%, so 7% increase. So what does that tell us in industry? In industry, that tells us that the criminals want cards with more data points with those personal contact details. Why? Because they're gonna start to try and work your customer. The way we look at, you know, CTI and fraud fusions, you probably heard that term, is that, you know, we live in a castle. Right? If you're in a financial industry, you live in a castle, and you protect your castle. Your customers, people that are customers of banks, for example, are the the civilians, and they these civilians can go outside the castle walls. And we try and protect those civilians out there, and we'll put some armor on them. But there's only so much armor we can put on them. Essentially, they're out there on their own, and we are in a castle. And our castle may be secure, but those individuals outside of castle, maybe not so much. And there's only so much armor we can put. And criminals, more and more, are trying to work on that. Right? So they're trying to get a lot more data points on that customer that is out there outside of castle walls. So that's why we're seeing a lot more data points being collected in whether it's scams, whether it's the MAGE card infections, whether it's a phishing attack. As I said before, about $15 is your average cost of cards. In the next couple of slides, we'll talk about, well, what can you do with a card? Another interesting point, outside of those 180,000,000 cards that we collected, from that are for sale, we've also collected about 80,000,000 cards out in the open for free. These are free cards just out there. You know where we collected most of them? Telegram. I'm sure you've heard of Telegram. Telegram became this new medium of crime. Back in the day, you needed to have a hoodie to go on the dark web, and you need to know how to use Tor network and VPNs and have special access. Nowadays, you download an app, and that app has, like, a lot of cool tools. And that app is free. And there's a lot of groups you can join, and there's a lot of crime happening there. So it really became this interesting place, and there's a lot of card data floating out there. So, yeah. Very, very interesting changing environment. Alright. So $15. I got my credit card. What can I do with it? Well, I can bypass sanctions. I can travel. Oh, how cool is that? Let's get into this. So here on top left, you can see some of the threat actors on the forum saying, hey. Look. What what can we do? Well, you know, how do how do I get stuff? Well, firstly, you wanna buy things that are easy to sell because you want cash. You wanna cash out that card. You bought it $15, you wanna make money. Right? So you can buy an iPhone. An iPhone is it's easy to sell at a discount. You bought it full price. You sell it at a discount. Easy money. But, you know, now we're dealing with the Russian war. Right? For example, I'll use Russian as an example. Russia has been sanctioned quite heavily. Their citizens are unable to use their Russian cards or Russian bank issued cards anywhere in the world. Well, you can get some American cards. You can buy them, and then you can use them anywhere. Right? Well, Russia was sanctioned also on various things for their military. Right? Like military equipment. Well, if you're using a stolen card from an American or, you know, Brit, yeah, you can buy whatever you want. You wanna buy night vision goggles? You wanna buy drones? You wanna buy scopes? You wanna buy electronics? No problem. It's American issued card. And then you say, well, how do I how do I how do I ship it back? Well, there's actually reshipping services in United States. You know, most of the time, you know, we we as Americans think of, like, oh, yeah. You got UPS, FedEx, and USPS. Well, no. There's actually a lot of logistic companies in United States that do international shipping outside of those three. And and some of them maybe specialize in different areas. There's, you know, one operating out of New York, for example. And they're willing to ship anywhere in Europe, including Russia, including Ukraine, including all these other places. But not only that, you can actually transfer some of your crypto to them and they'll issue you a virtual credit card. You can go shop then in United States, that's why, for example. You get the goods, you ship it to them as a shipping address, and then they'll reship it for you anywhere in the world. Pretty easy. Right? Alright. Why not travel? That's another cool one that they do. So there's actually on the dark web, you can see two screenshots from the dark web of travel services that are being advertised to criminals by criminals. How do these travel services work? Well, they have a lot of stolen credit cards, and they buying plane tickets, hotels. They're buying yacht well, yacht trips. They're booking weddings at huge discounts. You can buy plane tickets 50% off. Business class, 50% off. Hotels, you know, 75% off. 25% off. Whatever you want. Sounds great. Right? Alright. They can also do something called ghost booking. That's when they're in on it with the you know, somebody say, for example, from Airbnb, they have a place, they'll make a deal with them. They'll say, hey. You know, I'll just use this stone credit card to pay for this, and we'll split the profits. Yeah. That can happen as well. So the world of fraud, the world of sort of how things are working with fraud and and how these cards are used is very vast. And as we kinda talk about this and built this as a foundation for this sort of understanding, what can you do with the credit cards and what that marketplace looks like and what that ecosystem looks like. I now wanna talk about scams and how they fit into these pictures. So scam, scam, scams. So if you are in a banking industry, I'm gonna ask you, what is scams? And and you're gonna give me an answer. And I'm gonna ask somebody else in the banking industry what is scams, and they're gonna give me a different answer. I'm gonna ask 10 other people, and they're all gonna give me different answers. I'm gonna ask somebody in a crypto industry where it's scams, and they're gonna give me a third answer. And I ask somebody that works at the dealership, they're gonna have a different answer. So it's a very broad just like fraud, scams is a broad subject. So I'm gonna narrow it down to certain things that we can kinda all agree on maybe, and we can follow along. So let's talk about the basic kind of scam, and you probably heard of this as a phishing scam. Right? So phishing is something that is where people are trying to get information out of you. They can be phishing you for information, for your personal details. But they can also be phishing you for credit cards. Right? And this is where getting into these sort of text messages that you've been receiving. Hey. Have you paid your toll? Right? We all are tired of those. You have a package. We need a payment from you. How tired are you of those? Right? Pretty cool. We investigated those actually. So pretty interesting. Right? So they are fishing for your information. So you go on that pay the toll, they're gonna tell you, hey. Put in your credit card number and you put in that number. Once you put it in, that's it. They stole it. That's a stolen card. What I do with that card number? Well, they go to a carding shop and they sell it, or they'll take that card number and they're gonna go shopping with it. They can do something called NFC Relay with it. NFC Relay is the next step, and this is where we see a progression of this sort of phishing scams because a lot of people were like, oh, this is actually easy to do. We can actually get a lot of cars. There's a lot of money involved in this. So now you have these professional organizations getting involved in this. So now these phishing attempts are becoming more advanced. So the advancement that we've seen is they put the card not only are they stealing your card number, then they try and put that card number onto a mobile wallet. So what happens is you put in your card number, the website tells you, wait, we're loading, we're verifying your payment. On the back end, your credit card goes onto you know, you see on the screen that screenshot a bunch of mobile phone numbers or, mobile phones. It goes into one of those phones and it pings, hey, somebody enter the card detail, and and then there'll be a guy or gal that comes up to that phone. Okay. Add this card to a mobile wallet. What happens when you add a card to a mobile wallet? Well, your bank is gonna send you a verification code. Right? So then on the page, the phishing page, the initial one where you, it says, hey, processing your payment. It's gonna tell you, hey, your bank needs to verify this payment as legitimate. We the bank will send you a code. We need that code. You get a legitimate code and then you as a customer get a legitimate code in your phone from your bank saying, hey, this is the the the code. You enter it in the website thinking you're confirming the payment, but what you actually are doing is you're confirming getting your card added to a mobile wallet. What they can do later is called, NFC relay attack, and that's when they can use phone in one country. And then they can, do some, shopping in another country. Ask me about this later. It's it's a little bit different topic. But nevertheless, what I'm trying to say is that it's an advancement, and they are advancing in how they're doing these different things and what is happening in this world. Alright. So let's switch gears. So phishing was one of them. Right? They're stealing your cards, and that's how can supply the market. But let's talk about scam sites, and this is my favorite part. And I kinda take pride in this in this part of the presentation because it all started a few years ago when I was sitting on a well known social media site looking at cat videos and cat pictures. I was scrolling along and I see this great pair of pants. I'm like, oh my god. I need these house pants. They're like $20. These pants look great. And, you know, I again, social media site, everybody knows it. You know, I get an ad within that social that's gotta be legit. Right? That's you know, I'm not thinking, like, oh, this is something fraudulent. So I go on that, you know, follow the link on the ad, and I ordered the pants. I paid the $20, and I forget about it. You know, it's $20 pants. I forgot about it. You know, it was a kinda like a moment thing, you know. They kinda look like that in the picture. Right? And, so, you know, a couple months later, you know, I like we're we're working fraud. Right? We collect the card data from dark web and boom, I get a ping that my card is actually on the carding shop. I'm like, woah. Woah. Woah. How did that end up? I'm I'm the fraud guy. I I run the fraud department. How did my card end up there? And, I started investigating. I go back to this, purchase of pants. So I get back to my team. I'm like, hey, guys. Let's investigate this. Mind you, this is, like, three, four years ago. So we started investigating. Yeah. It was easy. That website was still operational. That's campsite. They're still operational. It had a social media page. You know, you go, on the website and you read about them. There's some typos. There's some spelling errors. It was easy to tell that it was actually not very legitimate. I didn't do due diligence at the time when I was buying, but now I'm looking at it like, yeah. I should have been able to tell this is a scam. And we said, oh my god. Well, how many of these scam sites can we actually find? So then we started doing a little bit of research into them. Oh my god. We actually unraveled a whole bunch of these scam sites that were out there. They were easy to link them because, you know, you take some names and did some phone numbers that were listed. These numbers were fake and you plug it into a Google search and you find other websites with that phone number. Or you take an address and that address goes in the middle of the field, but you put it in a Google search, you find other website. It was easy to find. We unraveled the whole network of of those scam sites. And the premise of those scam sites was not only were they stealing cards, but they were also charging people money. And back then, nobody could detect it. Nobody knew what to do with it. So they could have been operational for months at a time, six months, eight months at a time. Imagine how much money they were making. Right? And it and it was self perpetuating crime because they steal the card data. Now they can use that card data to pay for the ads. That's genius. That's well, genius. Not genius, but that that that's a horrible crime. They are unlimited in how they can actually spread it. But again, this is many years ago. This is like when this we started seeing trends of this and we were like, oh my god. This is gonna become a problem. This is gonna be like, a huge problem now because how do we fight this? Nobody's fighting this. So, yeah, they were really abusing a lot of this trust sort of things that we had with the the social media that we were kinda using, the search engines that we were using, they started abusing it at scale. And over the years, as we continue to keep tabs on it, this has become one of our main products now. Well, maybe not main products, but it's one of our key products that we are now offering to our clients is scam merchant monitoring because we're identifying these, you know, every day my guys are out there fighting these scam sites to try and identify this. But as we are nearing the holiday season, I wanna kinda point out that it is time when the scam sites become very active. This is the time where they're gonna really be pressing on these holiday themes. Holiday themes, you know, we have examples here with Halloween. This is from less than a month ago. This is fresh data. These are ads that were being run on the well known social media site. Again, they're using these sort of like, hey, Halloween special. This is a huge discount. This is your opportunity to buy things. They look like they're from legitimate pages. They're not. You look in the comments. You may actually see comments from people that say, oh, yeah. I bought this product. It's really great. You know, we're getting the product. That's fake. It's fake. Don't trust them. Right? And then we've seen it cross posting to, like, different ads actually. Same comments from different people. They call them bots, you know, I guess, or bots. Yeah. So sort of yeah. That's what they do. So and, again, because they have unlimited budget, and they have unlimited budget because they're stealing cards, your cards, they're using your cards to pay for the ads. They don't care how much they spend. Right? It's not their card. So imagine this, just running wild, while running rampant. However, industry is trying to fight it somewhat. You know, we are trying to, you know, your clients, if you are an issuing institution, are probably complaining. Look, I got scammed. You guys gotta do something. Right? You know, some scam sites do get shut down. So they started to get shut down. Well, alright. Well, how how do we keep those scam sites running longer? How do we kinda, like, not get shut down? So that's when they becomes a lot more complex. Right? And, again, remember, this is I I I I saw some, statistics, right, for for last year, I believe. Somebody said scam industry is a trillion dollar industry. Now scam, again, broad term, it probably includes all the things, everything scam. Somebody got scammed out of a goat. But, you know, it it this is a multi billion dollar industry relating to this. So now you don't just have those hackers with hoodies sitting, you know, in their grandma's bedroom doing this. This is, like, very, you know, organized crime groups are getting involved in this. These are legitimate if you wanna call them companies that are hiring legitimate individuals, professionals in marketing, you know, somewhere out in China, that are having an actual office, professional office. And these people are, like, coming up with strategies. How do we keep these scam sites lasting longer? Right? So, yeah, a lot of involvement in that. And, obviously, you know, they are using the dark web criminals, and the dark web criminals also are happy to play along with them. During the holidays, criminals also have discounts. During the holidays, the forums also when dark web criminals informs the hackers, they advertise. They have criminal Black Friday. So they'll be on the forums. They say, hey. You guys wanna buy bunch of cards at very discounted rates? Holiday season. You know, why not be jolly? We have promotions. Hey. You wanna buy a stolen server for a discount? Sure. Why not? We got sales as well. So they kinda mirror what we do in a regular life. Right? So, the dark web promos, you have sort of them escaping these detection methods of making the sites last longer. You have emotional triggers. Everybody's ready for holiday season. You are ready for sales. Right? You are ready for those big discounts, and that's what usually scammers are trying to do. They they selling you air. They're not selling you. These scam sites are not selling you any product. They're selling you air. So their discounts are always heavily discounted, and this is the right season to be discounted. So that's an emotional trigger for you. And then we're using malicious ads on the sources that we trust normally. Right? I'm on the social media talking to my grandma. This is a place I trust, you know. So alright. So let's get into the red flags of things. Right? So Black Friday and Cyber Monday, those are gonna be big ones coming up. We're also gonna have Christmas stuff happening. Right? So that's not far ahead. And then we're gonna have any other holidays. Right? This doesn't just apply to this season. It's gonna be continuous. Every sort of event is happening, it's gonna bring along this. So big discounts, lowering the guard. People are like, hey. This is perfect time to buy that pair of Nike's for really cheap or or an iPhone. You're not gonna be surprised that there's sales. Right? Look, there's a a site. This is a fresh scam site that we recently discovered selling dresses at huge discounts, which is, again, it's not really raising red flags because you're used to you're accustomed to, to sales, during this time. Right? And, again, the criminals, they're ready too. They're like, hey. We can help you. We can help you launch these campsites. Hey. We can actually give you landing pages if you want. You know, we can set things up for you if you want. No big deal. And remember how I told you that a lot of professional organizations that get involved with scams, has the large profits. Again, this is like a deeper dive a little bit, but this is what it sort of looks like. We're gonna be quick here on this slide, but there's some called transactional laundering. Right? So the way it works here is that you have a customer, you have a scam shop, which is a scam site, then you have a payment, payment that is being routed to legitimate looking merchant, then you have that payment go into acquire MPSP, and the money goes into the fraudsters bank account. But again, they can move that payment page. So for example, again, back in the day, it was all on the same site, the the the early scam pages. Nowadays, you have a scam page that is separate, and that's gonna sell some something. And then when you click pay, it's gonna take you to a different page or different website. And that website may not sell anything at all. It may just look like a a payment page. And then you're gonna make a payment there. So what they're trying to do is actually they're trying to kinda hide how their payment sort of system is working. They're trying to disassociate that payment processing or that payment site from the actual scam site. So, you know, look, you as a customer, you may go to your bank and say, hey. Look. I got scammed on this site, and the bank says, okay. We'll go to that site. There's no payment processing there, so we can't block it. We can't do anything with it. And a lot of times, they don't follow the sort of the the breadcrumbs into the next page where they get redirected where an actual payment processing is posting. That payment processor has a merchant ID, and this is a product placement a little bit. And this is where we kind of what we do is we we we do some of the testing. We try and identify these sort of, merchant IDs and we're trying to identify, well, where does this scam page what kind of payment processing are they associated with? What kind of merchant ID is actually attached to this? But again, they do transaction laundering and then they'll move it around. That payment page, that may actually be associated oh, I think it disappeared. My presentation. Sorry. Alright. So that payment page may actually be hidden somewhere. There we go. Alright. We're back on it. So redirects, again, that kind of follows along. Right? You have a search result, you have an ad, you have a ad server, and it redirects you to different pages. Depending on the area, maybe the scammers are targeting people only in United States. Maybe they don't want people from Europe to enter these scam sites. So they're gonna actually have checkpoints along the way in the scam process to filter out the traffic they wanna see. Hey. Is this a target user? Is this somebody we we actually want? And then they also look at device, fingerprint. Are people answering this from a mobile device? We've seen that as well. Look. If you go from a meta ads, for example, you click on that ad on the meta and it redirects you to scam page and you are using a cell phone, then you will see the actual scam content. But if you're using your computer and you're trying to access this scam site, it won't show it to you. It shows maybe a regular site or redirect it to a legitimate site, or it may show you that the website doesn't work. If you use a computer and you use the redirect from the ad, it may not show it to you either. So they are coming up with these very creative ways in how to kind of, make those scam sites last longer. And again, this is because you have a lot of professionals involved. They understand how marketing works. They understand how ads work. They understand how researchers work. They, you know and and and that creates sort of this complex chain of detection. And a lot of times, not everybody on the, you know, on the industry side is gonna go through all the steps and and connect all the dots. Thankfully, we have been doing that. So, we we are very proud of our product. Alright. Let's talk about other scams. Cat scams, my favorite ones. No. I'm kidding. So again, you know, pet scams, they call them. Right? That still is happening. These are old old scam type of stuff. I I've seen these a while back. Hey. I have these, you know, cats or I have these puppies. I can sell them to you at a discount. This is like some crazy breed of huge discounts. Send me money. That's a scam. You know, you have your subscription scams. That's a cool one. We've seen one where it says, hey. Enter a phone number, and for $1, we can track that phone wherever it travels. You're like, oh, cool. $1. I can track my ex girlfriend, whatever. And then you enter your credit card details and it tells you, oh, I'm sorry. We can't track that phone. You know, whatever. Something, a glitch. And you're like, whatever. It's a dollar. Who cares? But what you actually signed up for is a subscription service. And now you're paying $20 a month for something that you didn't know you were subscribing to. Canceling it? Almost impossible. You you you're gonna try and contact them. They're not gonna respond. Blah blah blah. The only way is to go to your bank and say, look, I gotta change my credit card. I don't I'm getting keep you in charge. So these are subscription scams. They do lotteries. They they do all kinds of stuff. Romance scams. These have been around since Helen of Troy. Some say that was the original romance scam. But in any case, those are still happening. People still fall for these. They are becoming more advanced. A lot of well, more recently, I've seen them where it it will be, you know, a female that context, you know, males in these male centric groups, maybe like car groups or whatever. And then they'll start chatting with them and then they'll lead them into this crypto thing. Hey. I'm doing this script. You can make a lot of crypto. They scam that way. So they are getting more advanced. Charity scams, that's a heartbreaking one. You know, there's a veteran one. I I have on the screenshot there. I'm a veteran myself. I've seen that one before. I thought it was all legitimate. And and usually when you donate to, like, these, charity organizations, it's always hard to to know where your money is going. Right? Like, you guys probably all know, like, not all the money is going to the actual thing and sometimes the Facebook thing. So it's kinda always hard to say. But again, these guys were collecting it for years. That thing was there for years and it was a scam. It was not not really. Disaster scam. Something happens around the world. You know, you have hurricanes. You have war. You have anything. Scammers are you know, like, that that's the big payday for them. They see some kind of disaster. They're gonna be up there setting up funds. They they're gonna be trying to scam people. So with that being said, I'm gonna pass it on to Karina, and she's gonna tell you about other type of fraud and scams. Okay. So thank you for that, incredible overview. So we've seen how fraud can take many different forms from fake online stores to fishing to travel agencies. But the whole system, like, the money, fake companies, reshippers still needs one thing to keep moving. So they need people. And that's where job fraud comes in. So these schemes exploit real human behavior, especially in tough economic times or just, like, right now during the holiday season when everyone's looking for a bit of extra income. So, Ilya, do you want to make some easy money? Okay. So everybody does. And I think that's how almost every job scam starts. And today, we are going to talk about different, subtypes of job fraud, especially ones connected to financial fraud. So we'll start with the classic, money mules or just mules. Work from home job that sounds just completely legitimate at first. So we have two types of people involved, unwritten money mills and written money mills. So unwritten person may think that they are financial assistant or logistic coordinator, but in reality, they are just helping, fraudsters to move stolen money or goods. So they might be told to open a new bank account, and that account then becomes the exit channel for stolen funds, or they can receive products bought with compromised cards often abroad to some sanctioned countries. Others are told to register a company, which is later used to open merchant account for money laundering or for scam, for example. And some even act as customer support for scam call centers unknowingly participating in social engineering. So they can help you to buy a flight ticket. So no ticket, no money, only only scam. Also, we have these written meals. So they know what they're doing, but they just charge you a higher fee for that. But both of these types, they usually have the same the same bad ending with law enforcement. Alright. So, again, around holidays, these just ramps up. Fraudsters exploit seasonal job searches, remote work ads. They record numerals under the guise of gift delivery or payment processing jobs. And in December, like, posts like earn from home as a parcel handler, flood Facebook and Telegram. So it's just a trap. Please be very careful with that. The next topic we are going to talk about is oh, okay. It's crypto. Okay. This is one of the fastest growing recruitment category over there, especially among young younger audience. And the first thing scammers rely on is your confidence. Just because people who use crypto, they often think, I'm technical. I know the space. Nobody can scam me. And that overconfidence is exactly what criminals exploit. It can start with something as simple as this, text message over there. Your Coinbase withdrawal code blah blah blah. So even if you didn't request a withdrawal, many people just log in to check. They can't they they call this, number, to talk with the manual, for example. And the moment you react, scammers know that they've hooked a crypto user. So they can reach you via some text messages with crazy investment opportunities, or they can use Telegram, Instagram posts with some trading jobs, or, of course, influencer posts with some magical crypto platforms. So typical pattern looks like this. Victim register on a sleek looking looking platform. They make a deposit or connect their wallet, which is always a very bad idea. So the employer drains the money, from the wallet or just vanishes after some, some pump and dump coin launch. And we've seen influencer driven fraud like, Logan Paul's project follow that strategy just perfectly. So these campaigns usually spike during holiday investment boom when people look to make their bonus work for them. And it's, like, very emotional timing. Like, brief and formal are the perfect holiday combo. Oh, sorry for that for that. Sorry. Okay. So now let's move and talk about getting the insight mind for social engineering, and I'm going to tell you why. So every resume is an open dataset for fraudster. Job titles, skills, company names, all ready to be weaponized against you, your colleagues, your friends. Threat actors use LinkedIn sometimes to recruit unwitting professionals into some, illegal activity. For example, cease admins roles that actually manage ransomware infrastructure. Or they can conduct corporate espionage. Like, they can interview candidates just to learn learn how the, like, company system work. Or they can also deliver a malware via some test assignment to you, so please always check this, like, small document extension. It's also an entry point for business email compromise. So criminals learn who is who in the organization, and later, they can impersonate them just very convincingly. And around your hiring cycles, recruiters are, like, very active and so are imposters. So please watch out for these postings, especially for remote IT jobs or these finance job that seem too too generous. Alright. Now we are going to talk about pig butchering. Okay. So this is like a long form emotional version of fraud. I'll be rich type of scam. And, again, it thrives during the holiday when people are very more emotionally open, and at the same time, they financially pressured. So pig butchering is a, like, a very patient scam. Fraudsters build fake personas over weeks, months, sometimes, often posing as investment gurus on social media, romantic interests because everybody wants to be loved, and, mentors offering some wealth coaching. And they may show off some luxury lifestyle, old money vibes, like verified looking accounts. They also can build trust by letting the victim make some small withdrawals, like a confidence trick before the big loss. They also target sometimes the, like, older people with, this grandparents scam. They can call, you know, your grandchild is in danger, in prison, in hospital, so please give us your money, and we are going to help him. They can also exploit leaked personal data to sound, like, more more credible. In many cases, they use investment websites, like, sometimes even replicas of, legitimate portals. So in general, it's something like a mix of social engineering, OSINT, and fake infrastructure. And during holiday months, we see this, like, emotional manipulation spike. Invest before the new year or gift you yourself, like, financial freedom. So please don't. I mean, financial freedom is okay, but not not not this way. Okay. Checks. So let's shift to paper. So, yes, checks still exist. And, surprisingly, check, and tax frauds still remain, like, major cash out methods, especially for local crime groups. And, if you're someone who uses both, like, crypto and old school paper checks like Ilya, congratulations. You're basically on every fraudster's wish list. Alright. So fraudsters still checks from, mailboxes, post offices, and workplaces. So sometimes with inside their help, of course. Then they post photos of them, for sale on Telegram or Instagram. And just, by the way, Recorded Future collected over 2,700,000 stolen checks in 2024 alone. So these gangs are very active and organized, often traveling from ZIP code to ZIP code, and we also can just track it a little bit. And, while they're busy do it busy doing that, someone's grandmother might just trying to mail a Thanksgiving check to their children only for it to end up on Telegram and in our collection, of course. But even more profitable is tax tax refund frauds. So filing returns using stolen identities before the real taxpayer does. They can buy or trade these w two forms on dark web market. So you can see this, lucky kid there on the forum, trading this w two forum, forms. And they also exploit weaknesses in some verification tools like id. Me. So please file your returns as soon as possible, and you can, like, survive this this this danger. And. I'll add. a little bit here. And and as you can see in some of the screenshots, we obviously kinda talk about the dark web. I also mentioned the Telegram, and Telegram has become this sort of, again, a easy to use platform for criminal activity. And a lot of these sort of crime groups that were in the past, maybe were hidden away somewhere where we it was difficult to know how they were operating. We now have a good insight into, like, oh, yeah. We can actually see how they operate. We can actually kinda get an insight how these local criminal organizations operate. We know the the Russia or the old school hackers, the the the masterminds, they on the dark web. Right? And that's what they talk. But these are, like, sort of the end fraudsters, if you will. And then these are the guy you know, the company, like a home goods company, furniture store, whatever. And there's a a an employee there that is just has access to w twos of the other employees. And we just steal some of them and, well, what do you do? You can't go on a street corner and sell them. You can go on Telegram and you can take pictures and say, hey. I got these w twos, and it's easy for them to do that. And so these new platforms that are coming online again, Telegram is just one example, but, that's an example of how sort of technology is is kinda assisting in a lot of products. You know? Yeah. Very interesting. Alright. Thank you. And now we're going to talk about synthetic identity. So, it's like, profiles that look real on paper but don't actually belong to a real person. And let's imagine that I'm a fraudster, and I just want to do some bad stuff. And I don't have any, like, full information on someone, or I don't want to use my information, of course, for fraud. But I still want money. So I can do, like, a very unique same thing. I can, take a real Social Security number, often belonging to a child or someone who hasn't built any credit yet, and I can mix it with, some fake information. For example, made up name, fake address, fake phone number, email that looks consistent with the name. And then, they go online and apply for a credit or a loan using that information. So the bank sends the application to the credit bureau for verification, but the bureau replies, we have no records of this person. So, normally, that would be the end of it. No credit history, no approval. But, here is the trick. That first application quietly creates a new record inside the bureaus database. So the fraudster waits a bit and applies again, this time with a different bank. So when the second bank checks, the credit bureau does have this record and this identity. So it still has no credit history, but it's now exist as like a real person. And from that moment, the fraudster can start building a synthetic identity like credit profile, opening some small accounts, paying them off, slowly establishing trust. Over months, that identity becomes credit worthy. So when it mature, they go big, like high limit cards, loans, lines of credit, and disappear. So the hardest part here is there is no clearing victim. So Social Security number belongs to someone real, but the rest of the identity is completely fake. So no one reports it, and the bank take the loss, and detection can just last months or even years sometimes. So around the holidays, this problem grows. Those synthetic profiles that fraudsters built earlier this year are finally ripe, and they, they cash out it in, like, in q four when abnormal transaction can blend into the crowd of this, like, crazy shopping transactions. Alright. And, last but not the least, new account fraud. So this is, like, one of the most common endpoints for all these identity abuses. So fraudsters exploit how easy is to open, accounts online. COVID pushed most most onboarding fully digital and criminals adopted. So they use stolen personal information, forged IDs, often AI generated. This is, like, very modern right now, or they can use these synthetic identities to open new checking or credit accounts. These accounts then become the lunch pot for, like, payment fraud, money laundering, or scam merchant registrations. So in essence, everything we discussed today from meal jobs to pig butchering, eventually needs an account to move or store store stolen money. So that's why new account fraud is like a final link in this whole chain. And this is like a quick tour of this human side of fraud when social engineering meets just financial abuse. And the common theme here, as we can see, it's like opportunity meets timing and holiday season amplified both. So people look for side jobs, quick returns, like, some emotional connection, love, and criminals exploits, like, every of those impulses. So whether it's, like, Christmas, a work from home opportunity, holiday crypto bonus, like investment before the New Year offer, the best gift you can, like, give yourself is skepticism. Yeah. So thank you. Thank you for listening. Thank you, Karina. So, one of the, things I've also as we are kinda coming here to the q and a, I wanna point out that in the docs section of this presentation, we do have a, our holiday fraud slash scam report. So, this report is not public yet. It's gonna be going live public, so you guys are getting special access to it ahead of time. And that really is hopefully, will prepare you, and it's gonna talk about a lot of different things we talk about here. But, again, it's gonna go deeper if you wanna know more. We're also gonna have our annual payment fraud intelligence report. This is for the year 2024, and this is where initially I was talking about the the the the statistics and the data, and that's gonna dive into that and major card infections and things like that. We also have a, a public report that deals with brand impersonation, again, online ads and how that scam infrastructure. So we'll give you a little bit of different angle on scams. We have the payment fraud demo, and that's gonna be demo of our module. You guys here for the recorded future presentation. So there was some product placement here again in the world of scam merchant identification, mage card, stolen payment cards, and and other things, stolen checks. We also have that and and stolen bank accounts. So we have that data set so you can request a demo and you can see a demo. Then you can see the recorded future more broadly, in action, and you can see another report, is the state of threat intelligence for 2025. So and then we're gonna open it up for questions if you have any. Alright. So so, here's the question. How can I tell a website as a scam? So okay. So we talked about that in the past, well, in the in the beginning of the presentation that early in the days, it was easy to tell something as a scam. That site did not look very legit. Like, it just, you know, a shady site. Nowadays, there's a lot of these templated websites that they can buy, especially, you know, we see a lot of scams that are centric on, you know, selling women's clothing or men's clothing or or, certain materials. So there are already templated websites that are built around that. On top of that, you have now AI, and AI is obviously kinda playing into this whole fraud ecosystem. I would I I had to say AI, but I don't give me coffee. But so, in any case and that is making things a lot more difficult to detect. But some of the signs is like, look, is there a phone number? Can you call that website, or can you call that company and speak to somebody specific to that case? Is there an address for that, you know, company that you're shopping on? Does that address goes to a real place, or is it going in the middle of the field? You know, are discounts too good to be true? You know, can you find that brand somewhere else? Can you do, like, a search of that brand somewhere and find it? Like, hey. It's been around for a while, or is this, like, a brand new? So those are some of the sites, some of the signs you can kinda go from. And, Karim, do you wanna, answer the next one? If we have identified a scam website, what should we do now? I'll pass it to you, please. Alright. No. That's fine. I'm happy to answer that. So, so again, you identify a scam site and kinda having just the scam site itself is not necessarily gonna give you a whole lot if you are an issuing institution like a bank. Okay. It's a it's a website. I can't block website. That's not my business. But, what you can do is you you can try and find merchant ID, and that's what we sort of built in our product. It's like we do test transactions on those scam sites to identify that merchant that is attached to it. So now that we have the merchant name and merchant ID, we can provide it to our customers, and what the customers can do is actually block transactions on their end. So, for example, if you're into institution and, you know, hey. This is a scam merchant. Let me put some rules in place that will block any transactions on that specific merchant. Now the second piece there, and if you wanna go more advanced, you probably should flag the cards that tried to transact with that merchant if you see that dataset. Like, if you tried if if you are able to see on your end that a card tried to ping that merchant, that card is now compromised. Because, again, remember, they're not only charging you money, they're stealing that card. Once that card is stolen, okay, we're gonna put some anti fraud measures on that card because it it probably will now see some fraud in the future. It's gonna be sold in dark web and so on and so forth. So so those are certain some of the things you can do with with the data. But I I will say this that we are, as some of you may know, we're working, when we were acquired by Mastercard, so we are, working actively. My team is actively building sort of, the the infrastructure for this so that, you know, and working together with Mastercard, we are working on different solutions for fighting the scam epidemic that that everybody's dealing with now, and there are solutions that will be rolling out fairly soon. And then, we will be fighting this sort of thing. And I got my bats Batman suit ready to go, and, we're gonna you know, we are we are ready. And I think if we don't have any other questions yeah. Please feel free to reach out to us. You know, again, I encourage you to read the documents that we are we have shared here in the doc files. And, yeah, feel free to add us on LinkedIn as well. So Yeah. Thank you. alright. Thank you. Bye.